You want to renovate your kitchen so you call in a carpenter. You tell him you want to have one of those recessed ceilings with lights over your new kitchen counter tops. The carpenter agrees and proceeds to cut a whole in the ceiling. As chunks of the ceiling fall down, sunlight suddenly streams onto those beautiful counter tops! The carpenter yells out, "Gosh lady! You didn't tell me you had a flat top roof!" That's the way a dentist feels when we cannot get x-rays. We really need to know what is going on inside the teeth and bone. Since X-rays were discovered back in 1895 by Wilhelm Conrad Röntgen, X-rays have been little understood by the public at large. It is an invisible, painless beam of radiation that passes through body tissues and projects a photogram of absorbed and non-absorbed radiation on a piece of sensitive film/sensor. Remarkable to most, but worrisome to others. Dentists use X-rays to look into mouths everyday. It is one of the main diagnostic tools used to find pathologies in teeth, and surrounding tissue/bone structure. The best case scenario is that nothing wrong is found in and around your teeth. This has been a source of contention between our office and a few patients over the years. They feel that if there has been no decay or pathology seen in years of routine radiographs, then they take it upon themselves to refuse these regular x-ray surveys. This is seen as tolerable in our office as long as it doesn't stretch longer than 2½ to 3 years. Any longer than that and it becomes supervised neglect between the doctor and the patient. Unfortunately in the eyes of the law, the neglect falls onto the doctors shoulders, and they are the ones who are held responsible for any undiscovered pathologies even if the patient did sign a refusal form stating they didn't want the x-rays in the first place. It would be equivalent to needing major surgery and not having a chest X-ray just because you told your surgeon you didn't want the chest X-ray. That would not fly in the medical profession, and it doesn't fly in the dental profession either. Collimation: The collimator is the "barrel" of the X-ray "gun". It is a lead lined tube that helps prevent radiation scatter. When X-rays are made inside the X-ray head, the radiation comes out in all directions. By shooting the X-ray "beam" down a lead lined tube, the scattered X-rays can be aimed and prevented from hitting everyone around the room. It also focuses the beam where it is wanted and limits the exposure. The ideal length of this tube is about 20-40cm, but longer distances are best. If you do not get the film positioned directly in the path of the X-ray beam you will not expose the whole film. To the right is a phosphorus plate that has a "cone cut". Cone cut is where the collimator was not aimed at the film properly and no radiation was available to expose the film. I actually had to pose this cone cut on my human skull that I studied in dental school because my staff uses a tool called the XCP to position the films properly and cone cuts are very rare in our office with that and/or similar devices. (Because these phosphorus "films" are reusable, once they are bent and the phosphorus layer is cracked, it shows up on every plate as a cracked white line afterwards until the plate is discarded). This is how a collimator helps prevent scatter radiation to the rest of the body and why organs like the thyroid gland are safe from dental X-ray scatter.
In some countries the patients are issued a "Radiation Card" to track how much medical x-ray radiation they have received so the medical system will not overdose its patient population over time. Dental radiation is not included on these cards, probably because the doses are too low to be significant. This is why it amuses me when a medical "authority" like Dr. Oz would go on the record (TV Show) and provoke war on the dental community for taking radiographs. The simplest radiograph he would take for the heart (he is a heart surgeon) is over 10 times more radiation than dentistry's highest radiation exposure (CBCT) and 10,000 times higher than a single dental film. All I am asking is that you, the patient, stop for one minute and put everything into perspective before refusing any dental radiographs, and that Dr. Oz reference the scientific literature before he offers advise outside of his expertise.
The Food and Drug Administration recommendations for taking routine dental x-rays are as follows:
Patient who have no decay and are not at risk of decay:
Leaded Apron:Leaded aprons are usually equipped with thyroid shields (all of ours are) that are lead lined to minimize X-ray scattered radiation. With the advent of digital sensors, which require smaller doses of radiation to receive the same or better information than from the old fashioned silver nitrate film, lead aprons have become less relevant. If all the National Council on Radiation Protection and Measure (NCRP) recommendations arefollowed, leaded aprons are actually not required. However, in our office leaded aprons are not hard to use, and are hanging where ever a X-ray is taken. For this reason it is used on every patient. Leaded thyroid shield or collar isattached to every one of our aprons in our office, and is especially important for children and pregnant women. Some offices use just a small thyroid shield when it willnot interfere with the X-ray exposure.
List of Medical/Dental Radiation Sources:As you look over the numbers below for the various medical (radiological) procedures that can be done to the human body, please note how low the dental exposures are compared to medical.
|Source of X-rays||Estimated Exposure (mSv)|
|Dental X-rays1 Periapical Radiograph (PA) D-speed Film1 Periapical Radiograph (PA) DigitalBitewings (4 D-speed films)Full Mouth Series (19 D-speed films)Full Mouth Series (19 digital)Panograph Panograph (digital) Cephlometric (digital) Cross Sectional Tomography Cone Beam CT (CBCT)||- - 0.00950.003250.0380.1800.060 0.019 0.004 0.002 0.002 0.093-0.310|
|Medical X-raysTSA Airport ScanLower GI Track RadiographLower GI (Barium/Fluoroscopy follow through )Upper GI Track RadiographUpper GI (Barium/Fluoroscopy)Barium Enema (Fluoroscopy) IV Pyelogram Chest X-ray (2 views) Film Abdomen Film Pelvis Film Hip Film (unilateral) Neck Film Upper Back Film Lower Back Film Extremity (arm,leg) Skull Film DEXA Scan (bone density) Brain CT Brain/Neck CTA/CTP Neck CT Head CT scan Mammography (screening) Abdomen CT scan Abdomen CT scan (liver) Chest CT scan Chest CT (PE study) Colonography CT scan Chest/Abdomen/Pelvis CT scan Abdomen/Pelvis CT Cardiac Angiogram CT Cardiac CT (calcium scoring) Barium Enema CT scan Virtual Colonoscopy CT Neonatal Abdominal CT scan Nuclear Medicine Lung scan (Ventilation/Profusion-VQ) Cardiac stress test (Technetium) Cardiac stress test (Thallium) Liver scan (HIDA) Renal scan Whole body PET scan Bone scan Tagged WBC study Gastric Emptying Study GI Bleeding study Thyroid scan Parathyroid scan Brain scan Urea Breath test Interventional Procedures Coronary Angiogram (diagnostic) Coronary Angiogram (stent, ablation) Pulmonary Angiogram Abdominal Angiogram Head/Neck Angiogram Pelvic Vein Embolization Endoscopic retrograde Cholangiopancreatography Transjugular Interhepatic Portosystemic Shunt||- 0.000254.0605.02.4406.0 8.0 3.0 0.500 0.70 0.60 0.70 0.20 1.00 1.50 0.01 0.10 0.001 2.00 16.4 6.0 1.50 3.0 5.3-8.0 15.0 5.8-7.0 15.0 3.6-8.8 9.9- 18.0 14.0 6.7-13, 16.0 3.0 15 10 20 - 2.2 9.4 40.70 3.1 2.6 14.1 6.3 6.7 0.40 7.8 4.8 6.7 6.9 0.003 - 3.0 15.0 5.0 12.0 5.0 60.0 4.0 70.0|
|Natural (Earth and Atmospheric)7 hour airplane flightDenver 1 year (outerspace) Radiation ExposureUS average total radiation exposure per year||-0.0200.5103.1|
- Adults should have bitewing X-rays every 2-3 years
- Teens should have bitewing X-rays every 1½-3 years
- Children should have bitewing X-rays every 1-2 years
- Adults should have bitewing X-rays every 1-1½ years
- Teens should have bitewing X-rays every ½-1 years
- Children should have bitewing X-rays every 6months until decay is controlled
"The Hypothetical Dental Patient" lifetime radiation exposure:This is going to be a very liberal dental case: At our office an 84 year old female could possibly receive a full mouth x-ray (FMX) every 5 years after the age of 18. She could have had 7 vertical bitewings every 1 to 1½ years which would roughly equal 217 periapical radiographs (PA). As a child, if she had bad caries, she could have had 2 to 4 bitewings every year from about 2-3 years old to 18 years of age which would be about 64 PA's. After looking through thousands of my own charts, patient rarely have more than 3 panographs and one cone beam CT (CBCT) so let me calculate those as well. (Digital radiographs)*
- 13 FMX 0.780 mSv
- 217 PA's 0.705
- 64 PA's (Pedo size) 0.208
- 3 Panographs 0.057
- 1 CBCT 0.310